Detective Regrets Wrongful Conviction: A Death Row Story

In this poignant recount, ex-detective Brian reflects on his pivotal role in the wrongful conviction of Robert Robertson, now on death row for two decades. The story begins in 2002 when Brian, as the chief detective in Palestine, Texas, was involved in the case of a 2-year-old girl, Nikki, who was brought to the hospital by her father, Robert, and later died of suspected shaken baby syndrome. Brian recalls the lack of emotion displayed by Robert, which led to his arrest and conviction for murder. Over the years, Brian transitioned from police work to ministry but never shook off the burden of Robert's case. His belief in the system began to crumble when Robert's attorney appeared at his doorstep years later, revealing new insights—Robert's autism and Nikki's pre-existing medical conditions, which were overlooked during the investigation and trial. Brian laments about the substantial discrediting of shaken baby syndrome by the medical community and acknowledges that doubt in Robert’s guilt is undeniable. Brian expresses deep regret for not considering other possibilities for Nikki's injuries and criticizes the justice system's inability to carry out fair executions, advocating for the abolition of the death penalty. The conversation ends with Robert's forgiveness and mutual prayers for justice and peace.