Make

Man Reflects on Wrongful Death Row Conviction after 20 Years

The New York Times

105

In 2002, Robert Robertson was convicted of his daughter's murder under the suspicion of shaken baby syndrome, largely due to the absence of emotional display, attributed later to autism. Brian, the then-chief detective, played a key role in the conviction but now realizes the dire errors made. Investigations were not thorough, and the medical condition of Nikki wasn’t fully considered. Shaken baby syndrome has since been discredited. As new information surfaced and advocates approached him, Brian's guilt grew, leading him to believe the death penalty is unjust. Robert's eventual diagnosis of autism explained his behavior, and Brian is now determined to rectify this wrong. The story underlines the flaws in the justice system and advocates for the abolition of the death penalty due to human fallibility.

Highlights

• Robert Robertson was convicted in 2002 for his daughter's death.
• Brian, the chief detective, initially believed Robert's guilt based on his unemotional demeanor.
• Robert's daughter, Nikki, suffered from severe medical conditions.
• Shaken baby syndrome was initially suspected but later discredited.
• Brian left police work and entered the ministry, but guilt lingered.
• Robert was later diagnosed with autism, explaining his lack of emotion.
• Brian regrets not considering other causes for Nikki's condition.
• Robert's attorney approached Brian, reigniting the case.
• Brian now believes the death penalty should be abolished due to human error.
• Robert forgives those who wronged him, hoping for justice.