Electoral College Flaws and Reform Options Discussed

Washington Post
24
0
In the closing class of a series from The Washington Post, host Christina Quinn discusses the flaws and potential reforms of the Electoral College. Historian Alex Kazar reveals significant defects in its current structure, namely its undemocratic nature where the candidate with the most votes may not win, and the win-or-take-all method that skews election campaigns towards swing states. Despite arguments for preserving the system to protect minority votes in smaller states, Kazar believes its antiquated design does not reflect today's political landscape. He outlines three alternatives to reform: a national popular vote, the proportional allocation of electoral votes, and the national popular vote interstate compact. While a national popular vote was nearly enacted in the late 1960s, it faced roadblocks in Congress. There is hope for future reforms as political dynamics change, but for now, the Electoral College remains. The discussion emphasizes the importance of voting, as it directly impacts the electoral process.
Highlights
  • • The Electoral College allows for candidates to win without the majority of votes.
  • • Its win-or-take-all structure focuses campaigns on a few swing states.
  • • Historian Alex Kazar emphasizes its flaws as undemocratic.
  • • Arguments for the system include protection of minority votes in smaller states.
  • • Kazar suggests the Electoral College is outdated and unfit for modern elections.
  • • Three potential reforms are proposed: national popular vote, proportional allocation, and interstate compact.
  • • The national popular vote previously gained bipartisan support but failed in the Senate.
  • • Changing the Electoral College may depend on future shifts in party dynamics.
  • • Voter turnout remains crucial as each vote contributes to state electoral outcomes.
  • • Despite its issues, the Electoral College persists as part of the election landscape.
* dvch2000 helped DAVEN to generate this content on 10/17/2024 .

More news